The classic logo review: everyone in the room says "I feel", and the final call goes to whoever is most senior. Whether a logo is beautiful is subjective; whether it works is testable. Five criteria move the review from taste to evidence—and all five come from the constraints VI faces in real use.
1. Recognition: can you spot it at three metres?
Recognition is not "distinctive"; it is being distinguishable when small, at distance, and at a glance. The test: shrink the logo to 8 mm wide, print it in black, mix it among icons from the same category, and ask someone outside the project to pick it out in three seconds. If they cannot, the form leans too heavily on detail, gradients, or colour.
2. Size adaptability: from app icon to facade
- At minimum size, do strokes merge or counters clog?
- Enlarged to a facade or vehicle, does the proportion still hold?
- Do horizontal, vertical, and symbol-only versions all exist?
Delivering only a horizontal lockup is the most common gap: e-commerce headers need square, app icons need symbol-only, shopfronts need vertical. One missing version gets improvised on site—and the improvised versions multiply.

3. Single-colour reproduction: does it survive without colour?
Invoices, stamps, screen printing, foil stamping, mono newspaper ads—no gradients, no colour. Convert the logo to pure black and pure white: if the structure collapses or the negative space fills in, the design depends on colour and will degrade in production.
4. Specifiability: can it be written into a manual?
A good logo can be quantified: construction ratios, clear space as a fraction of cap height, minimum size in millimetres, permitted background range. If these cannot be written down, no specification exists—and every outsourced job produces a new version.
5. Business fit: does it say who you are?
The most neglected criterion. The logo need not depict the business, but its character must match the sector and price tier. Look at group projects such as Guangdong State Farms: agriculture and state-owned background call for stable, structured lettering. A light handwritten style would be unsuitable however recognisable.
6. Turn the five into a scorecard
Score each dimension 1–5 and write one line of justification. It beats a show of hands:
- Recognition: 5 = identifiable when shrunk and mixed; 3 = needs a hint
- Size adaptability: 5 = three versions, clear minimum size; 3 = horizontal only
- Single colour: 5 = works in black and white; 3 = needs adjustment
- Specifiability: 5 = parameters ready to issue; 3 = mock-ups only
- Business fit: 5 = matches sector and tier; 3 = neutral
Anything under 3 is homework before sign-off. The logic is identical to the full VI design checklist: first make it governable, then make it beautiful.
Conclusion
A logo is the smallest unit of identity and the most-used one. Asking "where will this fail?" is far more productive than arguing about which version is prettier.
We deliver three lockups and specification parameters with every identity, so nothing has to be redrawn after launch. To assess whether an existing logo is worth changing, start with an evaluation through brand design or call +86-400-6619-020.
